Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Colin Powell and Ben Affleck Address the Muslim/Arab Issue

For a while, it felt like it was simply becoming okay to accept the answer to the "Barack Obama is a Muslim!" rumor by saying, admittedly correctly, that he's not, he's a Christian, and he has never been Muslim. Despite that, about 13% of Americans still believe that Obama is Muslim.

Colin Powell, in one of the most well-thought out, articulate endorsements of any this year, finally made the distinction between the "correct" answer and the "right" answer to this question:

I'm also troubled by – not what Senator McCain says – but what members of the Party say, and it is permitted to be said: such things as, "Well, you know that Mr. Obama is a Muslim." Well, the correct answer is he is not a Muslim. He's a Christian; has always been a Christian.

But the really right answer is, "What if he is? Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in this country?" The answer's "No, that's not America."

Is there something wrong with some seven-year-old Muslim American kid believing that he or she could be President?

Yet, I have heard senior members of my own Party drop the suggestion he's Muslim and he might be associated with terrorists. This is not the way we should be doing it in America.

I feel strongly about this particular point because of a picture I saw in a magazine. It was a photo essay about troops who were serving in Iraq and Afghanistan.

And one picture at the tail end of this photo essay was of a mother in Arlington Cemetery. And she had her head on the headstone of her son's grave. And as the picture focused in, you could see the writing on the headstone. And it gave his awards – Purple Heart, Bronze Star; showed that he died in Iraq; gave his date of birth, date of death. He was twenty years old.

And then at the very top of the headstone, it didn't have a Christian cross. It didn't have a Star of David. It had a crescent and a star of the Islamic faith. And his name was Karim Rashad Sultan Khan. And he was an American.

He was born in New Jersey, he was fourteen years old at the time of 9/11 and he waited until he could go serve his country and he gave his life.

Now, we have got to stop polarizing ourself in this way. And John McCain is as non-discriminatory as anyone I know. But I'm troubled about the fact that within the party we have these kinds of expressions.
A separate incident a little over a week ago at a McCain-Palin town-hall meeting featured a woman who told John McCain that she was afraid of an Obama's presidency because he's "an Arab".

This time, it was Ben Affleck who addressed it best on Friday's Real Time with Bill Maher (starting at 5:20 in the clip):
"...(John McCain) said, "No he's not an Arab, he's a good man."

What if someone said, "I heard he was a Jew..." and I said, "No, no, no, he's not a Jew, he's alright..."? 'Arab' and 'good person' are not antithetical to one another!

We've allowed this idea, denying the fact that Obama - who, yes, is not an Arab, nor is he a Muslim - (that) we've allowed that denial to turn into the acceptance of both of those things as a legitimate slur is really a problem.

Instead of standing up and saying these aren't slurs, these are categories of human beings, they're not slurs of people - no one in the media stood up and said that. And instead they just follow around Joe the Plumber, it's the same bullshit they do every fucking day over and over again."
Despite the fact that Obama is neither Muslim nor Arab, his historic campaign may give rise to a more balanced national dialogue not only on race, but on what has been another kind of bigotry - one that is novel and easily overlooked, but just as significant.

12 comments:

CKAinRedStateUSA said...

Obama may not be a Muslim, if you believe those "expert" mouthpieces you reference, but I doubt seriously he's a Christian either, regardless of what he says."Out of the gate, Powell lies about Obama's 'Christianity.'"

Ali A. Rizvi said...

I agree. His father was an atheist and his mother agnostic. I think he found religion in his 20s to form connections as a community organizer in South Chicago.

Being a Christian or a Muslim or a Jew is essentially the same thing from my standpoint. A kook from one cult should have the same opportunities as a kook from another.

CKAinRedStateUSA said...

You'd be very wrong about your assessment about Christians, Muslims and Jews.

"A kook from one cult is as good as another"?

Mock as you will.

I pray you understand before you no longer have the opportunity to understand.

Besides, insulting others is not really a way to persuade anyone, is it, really?

Ali A. Rizvi said...

I know, I was just having fun with that last line - remember, this piece is against religious bigotry. But I did forget to throw in an emoticon - my bad, and you're right.

On a serious note, I do think it's about time to get rid of religion as a qualifying OR disqualifying factor for the presidency. It should have no place in a campaign. The Founding Fathers didn't think so (some of them were virtually anti-religion, like Adams, Jefferson, Franklin, etc), and they're right.

The bottom line is, Obama can be a Muslim, he may not be a Muslim, he may not be a Christian either, or a Jew, and he may not even be an atheist - whether he is or he isn't any of these things really should not be of consequence.

I don't think either Obama or McCain are especially religious. But they can't say that - specially McCain - because it might cost them the election.

docanwar said...

There's very little doubt about Colin Powell's presidential demeanor and rhetoric. And the point is well made. I think a distinction can be made between cults and major religions (roots in history, social reform, composition of followers etc). Finally, I think being "religious" is such a subjective term, and I agree with its exclusion from the political arena. What would work much better is articulation of clear positions on social, economic and foreign policy issues.

Anonymous said...

Well, this is area Pandora jewelry chaplet appear into play; pandora chaplet are a affably avant-garde section of jewellery that is demography the apple by storm, and accept been apparent decrepit and dangling from several A-list celebs in the pages of appearance magazines.

wedding flowers said...

To select from is indeed significantly wide that you will find elaborate jewelry designs in addition to elegant and straightforward designs. pandora.Buying clothes for comfort can also be yet another practical factor. However, we have a pre-conceived notion that comfortable clothes are not usually stylish and cause you to be appear cool. pandora uk.Positive thing there exists Ed Hardy Clothing. These clothes, although stylish, come in lightweight and comfortable material - permitting individuals to move freely. pandora. A person word of advice-I would prevent acquiring any specific silver jewelry that's not sterling. Pandora Jewelry. Repelling any terrible ingredient during the heavy snow as well as nippy wind, it keeps toes warm along with dry anytime all through winter. ghd sale.Necklaces who have similar sized beads work effectively on tall women and chokers help decrease each side height. ghd straighteners.It truly is accurate cheap Ugg Boots provide method aficionados terrific in addition to broad possibilities to spice up their shows. rrncluding a white and pink compact mirror.ugg boots sale.Longer necklaces aid lengthen each side round or square faces.wedding rings Furthermore they add length when worn beneath the bust-line but above the waist.

wedding shoes said...

This can be renowned now for the styles. The styles of Sabo are exclusive and loved globally. This jewelry possesses the honor of being thought to be most magnanimous present that you can at any time give.
Pandora Jewellery
pandora bracelets
pandora uk
wedding rings
wedding cakes
mother of bride dresses
wedding bride dresses
thomas sabo uk

mulberry sale said...

There are styles to present flowers in the front of the blue bridal shoes pandora uk, or beautifully decorated straps that encircle the ankles, pumps that are exquisitely adorned with rhinestones pandora bracelets, not to forget also the choice of beaded flowers that can decorate the blue color of your bridal shoes Pandora Jewellery.You can choose the others that have the pointed toe heels presenting a sparkling stone brooch that decorates the 4” high heels in front conferring the design a very elegant look Mulberry uk. And not to leave yet the luxurious style of blue bridal shoes Mulberry bags, you can choose the 4”heel height of the shoes that are decorated with a bow and great choice of rhinestones making them a perfect choice not only for the blue wedding gown, but also for any other cocktail dress.

youtube downloader said...

This is just ridiculous... I wonder who on Earth spreads such rumors and who believes them despite everything...

Emerald said...

It can't really have effect, I believe this way.

Ronald Scott said...

Sexy Lingeries, Dresses, Club Wears

Sexy Lingeries
Sexy Club Wears
Sexy Costumes
Fashion Dress
Elegant Dress
Loveuseeme Sales
Loveuseeme New
Fashion Blog
Chic, Stylish, Fashion Blog

Sterling Silver Jewellery .